Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

IntelliJ has much more functionality than Slack so it's a poor choice to compare it to. Also... comparing slow cross platform tool to another sluggish cross platform tool isn't really a great place to start.

The fact that this Rip Cord does 99% of what Slack does and uses a fraction of the memory and runs faster pretty much says it all. Javascript/ Electron are resource hogs.



Badly written Javascript/Electron apps are resource hogs.


Compared to virtually any compiled language, Javascript is a resource hog, regardless of how well written.

It is also single-threaded (without workers, which have their own limitations), and any large calculation can block that main thread.


Sure, it may be efficient but what percentage of feature compatibility do you think they'll be able to reproduce and maintain?


Largely depends on how quickly Slack/ Discord move their APIs and how aggressively those platforms block this kind of app. This has little to do with app performance though. Slack is a sluggish pig because the way it's written, not because of it's feature-set




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: